Michael McVinney — ERA Real Estate, Team VP

MLMcVinney & Associates, LLC

Elite Commercial Real Estate.Chautauqua Lake & Western New York

Ranked #1 in WNY. Harvard trained. CBRE background. Unmatched depth in the Great Lakes region.

Michael L McVinney, Commercial Real Estate Broker

The Standard

The region's most demanding deals end here.

Before launching MLMcVinney & Associates, Michael spent years at CBRE, one of the largest commercial real estate firms in the world. He holds a Harvard Real Estate Management certificate (MMP).

Ranked the #1 commercial real estate broker in the WNY/Chautauqua region in 2022, Michael draws on a construction-industry background that most brokers simply don't have.

When the deal is complicated and the stakes are real, clients in the Great Lakes region call one number.

#1

Broker in WNY (2022)

Harvard

Management Cert.

Michael L McVinney, commercial real estate broker, Jamestown NY
Michael L McVinney, WNY commercial real estate broker, downtown
Michael L McVinney, elite commercial real estate broker, Western New York

The Market

Chautauqua Lake & Western New York

Chautauqua Lake and Western New York are easy to underestimate. Serious buyers and sellers know better.

Waterfront property on Chautauqua Lake

Waterfront Real Estate

Celoron Hotel on Chautauqua Lake, commercial development

Commercial Development

Dock at sunrise, Chautauqua Lake investment properties

Investment Properties

Industrial commercial property, Falconer NY — Western New York industrial real estate

Industrial Properties

Coverage Area

Key Markets

Deep local knowledge across Chautauqua County, the Buffalo metro, Erie PA, and the broader Great Lakes region.

Chautauqua County & Western New York

Commercial Hub

Jamestown, NY

The commercial and industrial center of Chautauqua County. Michael handles office, retail, multifamily, and mixed-use transactions throughout downtown Jamestown and surrounding corridors.

Waterfront & Lakefront

Chautauqua Lake

Specialist coverage for waterfront commercial properties, marinas, seasonal hospitality, and lakefront investment properties along the full perimeter of Chautauqua Lake.

Village & Seasonal

Bemus Point, NY

A high-demand lakefront village with strong seasonal hospitality, restaurant, and retail activity. Buyer and seller representation for commercial and investment properties in the Bemus Point corridor.

North Shore & Lake Erie

Westfield, NY

Gateway to Lake Erie's north shore, vineyard country, and regional tourism. Commercial property brokerage including retail, hospitality, and agricultural investment properties.

Industrial & Manufacturing

Falconer, NY

Active industrial corridor with light manufacturing, warehouse, and flex-space inventory. Michael brings construction-industry expertise to industrial acquisitions and dispositions in Falconer and southern Chautauqua County.

County Seat & Northern Lake

Mayville, NY

Chautauqua County seat on the northern tip of Chautauqua Lake. Office, municipal-adjacent commercial, and lakefront investment properties represented on behalf of buyers and sellers.

Cultural & Institutional

Chautauqua Institution, NY

The nationally recognized Chautauqua Institution grounds and surrounding village create a distinctive market for seasonal commercial, hospitality, and mixed-use investment properties along the western lakeshore.

University Town & Commercial

Fredonia, NY

Home to SUNY Fredonia and a strong downtown commercial district. Office, retail, and multifamily investment opportunities driven by the university community and proximity to Lake Erie and I-90.

Port City & Industrial

Dunkirk, NY

A Lake Erie port city with active commercial and industrial corridors. Dunkirk offers waterfront redevelopment potential, industrial properties, and retail inventory along the Lake Erie shoreline in northern Chautauqua County.

Cattaraugus County, NY

Regional Commercial Center

Olean, NY

The commercial and retail hub of Cattaraugus County. Olean features a dense downtown corridor, retail centers along Route 417, industrial inventory, and multifamily investment properties serving the county's largest population center.

Gaming & Mixed-Use

Salamanca, NY

Home to Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino and a unique commercial environment shaped by Seneca Nation land and gaming-related economic activity. Commercial and hospitality properties in and around Salamanca offer distinctive investment characteristics.

Ski Resort & Tourism

Ellicottville, NY

Western New York's premier four-season resort destination, anchored by Holiday Valley and HoliMont ski resorts. Strong hospitality, seasonal retail, short-term rental, and mixed-use commercial activity in one of the region's most active resort markets.

Buffalo Metro — Erie County, NY

Regional Commercial Center

Buffalo, NY

Western New York's largest commercial market. Office towers, multifamily investment, mixed-use redevelopment, and industrial assets across the city's established business corridors and waterfront.

Airport & Distribution Corridor

Cheektowaga, NY

One of the region's most active industrial and logistics corridors, anchored by Buffalo Niagara International Airport. Warehouse, distribution, flex-space, and retail concentrated along the Walden Ave and Dick Rd corridors.

Waterfront Industrial

Tonawanda & North Tonawanda, NY

Historic manufacturing and industrial district along the Niagara River and Erie Canal. Strong inventory of waterfront industrial, redevelopment sites, and light manufacturing properties.

Suburban Office & Medical

Amherst & Williamsville, NY

The primary suburban office, medical office, and professional services corridor in northern Erie County. High-traffic retail, Class A office, and mixed-use assets along Transit Rd and Main St.

Warehouse & Logistics

Depew & Lancaster, NY

Active logistics, warehouse, and light manufacturing corridor east of Buffalo. Strong I-90 access and proximity to BUF Airport make this a prime target for distribution and industrial users.

South County Industrial

Hamburg & Lackawanna, NY

South Erie County corridor with diverse industrial, retail, and commercial inventory. Lackawanna's legacy steel sites offer significant redevelopment and heavy industrial opportunity.

Erie, PA Region

Regional Port & Commercial Hub

Erie, PA

The largest commercial market on the southern Lake Erie shore. Strong industrial, port-adjacent, waterfront redevelopment, and mixed-use investment opportunities across the city's established corridors.

Primary Retail & Office

Millcreek Township, PA

The dominant suburban retail and office corridor west of Erie. Dense commercial activity along Peach St and Route 20, with high-traffic retail centers, professional office parks, and national anchors.

Industrial & Distribution

Summit Township & Harborcreek, PA

Growing industrial and logistics corridor with strong I-90 access east and south of Erie. Significant warehouse, distribution, and manufacturing inventory serving regional supply chains.

Manufacturing & Light Industrial

Corry, PA

Established manufacturing base in southeastern Erie County with industrial, flex-space, and light-industrial property inventory. Accessible to both Erie and Chautauqua County markets.

Commercial Corridor

Fairview, PA

Commercial and light industrial corridor west of Erie along Route 20 and I-90. Retail, office, and industrial properties serving the growing northwest Erie County population.

Client Reviews

39 Five-Star Reviews

★★★★★

"Mike is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME. Talk about going above and beyond! I live long distance and he went right over to the building I was interested in on SEVERAL occasions to shoot video, virtually walk me around the entire property, met with contractors... everything. Can't say enough about this guy."

Mark WoodCommercial Buyer · via Google
★★★★★

"I've worked with Mike McVinney on numerous projects from Pennsylvania through New York and I can state, without reservation, that Mike is incredibly hard working and one of the most creative deal makers I have ever worked with. He is solution focused, and a consummate professional."

William PrietoMulti-State Investor · via Google
★★★★★

"Mike's professionalism and knowledge of commercial real estate is unmatched. He was able to find what we were looking for almost immediately. Highly recommended!!"

Crown Street Roasting CompanyCommercial Tenant · via Google
★★★★★

"I had the pleasure of working with Michael McVinney to purchase my dream lake house. Mike was incredibly knowledgeable about the local market, attentive to my needs, and always available to answer any questions I had. His professionalism and expertise made the entire process smooth and stress-free."

Matt ShortChautauqua Lake Buyer · via Google

InsightsCommercial Real Estate Q&A

Buying Commercial Real Estate

What is the first step to buying commercial real estate?

Start by defining how the property will be used and what the investment must accomplish. Consider the preferred location, building size, zoning, access, parking, loading requirements, utility capacity, occupancy needs and total budget.

Buyers who need financing should speak with a commercial lender early. A lender can help establish the likely down payment, debt-service requirements and price range before the property search begins.

Should I buy or lease commercial space?

Buying may make sense when you expect to remain in the location for several years, want control over the property and have enough capital for the down payment, closing costs, improvements and ongoing ownership expenses.

Leasing may offer more flexibility and require less upfront capital. The right decision depends on your business plans, available cash, expected growth and the cost of suitable properties in the local market.

Should I sell my current commercial property before buying another one?

That depends on your cash position, financing structure and ability to carry both properties.

Some owners sell first because they need the equity for their next acquisition. Others buy first to avoid disrupting their business or losing a strong opportunity. A purchase may also be structured around the sale of another property, financing approval or a potential Section 1031 exchange.

Your broker, lender, attorney and tax advisor should review the timing before you commit to either approach.

How much of a down payment is required for commercial real estate?

Commercial financing does not follow one standard formula. The required equity depends on the property, borrower, lender, loan program, cash flow and intended use.

Owner-occupied properties may qualify for different financing options than investment properties. Industrial buildings, vacant land, hospitality properties and redevelopment projects may also be evaluated differently.

Speak with a commercial lender before making an offer so the financing assumptions match the property being considered.

What should I evaluate before buying an industrial property?

Industrial buyers should look beyond the building's square footage and price. Key factors may include:

  • Zoning and permitted uses
  • Ceiling and clear height
  • Loading docks and drive-in doors
  • Truck access and turning radius
  • Floor load capacity
  • Electrical service and utility capacity
  • Sprinkler and fire-suppression systems
  • Outdoor storage rights
  • Rail or highway access
  • Environmental history
  • Expansion potential
  • Proximity to employees, customers and suppliers

The property must support the operation you intend to run, not merely the use of its current owner.

What due diligence should be completed before purchasing commercial property?

Commercial due diligence may include:

  • Building and structural inspection
  • Roof, mechanical and electrical review
  • Environmental assessment
  • Zoning and permitted-use confirmation
  • Title review
  • Survey review
  • Property tax analysis
  • Lease and rent-roll review
  • Operating expense verification
  • Utility and infrastructure review
  • Code and permit research
  • Flood-zone and drainage review
  • Appraisal and financing approval

The scope should reflect the property type, past uses and intended plans. Industrial sites, former automotive properties, manufacturing facilities and redevelopment sites often require additional environmental review.

Do I need an environmental assessment?

Many commercial and industrial buyers order a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment, especially when the property has a history involving manufacturing, automotive service, fuel storage, dry cleaning, chemicals or other industrial activity.

A Phase I assessment reviews historical records, prior uses, surrounding properties and visible conditions. The findings may lead to additional testing or a Phase II investigation.

Environmental review should be handled by a qualified environmental professional and coordinated with legal counsel and the lender.

How do I confirm that my intended use is allowed?

Review the municipality's zoning code and obtain written confirmation when appropriate. A property's current use does not automatically mean your proposed use is permitted.

Confirm whether the project requires:

  • A special-use permit
  • Site-plan approval
  • A zoning variance
  • Building permits
  • Environmental review
  • Parking or signage approval
  • Fire-code approval
  • State or county permits

Zoning and approval requirements can differ between municipalities across Western New York.

What is net operating income?

Net operating income, commonly called NOI, is the property's income after normal operating expenses but before debt payments, income taxes, depreciation and certain capital costs.

For an income-producing property, buyers should examine how the NOI was calculated and verify the underlying rents, vacancies, reimbursements and expenses. A seller's projected NOI should not be accepted without supporting documentation.

What is a capitalization rate?

A capitalization rate, or cap rate, compares a property's annual net operating income with its purchase price or market value.

Cap rate is one tool for evaluating an income-producing property. It does not account for every risk, financing cost, future capital expense or change in rent. Properties with similar cap rates can still have very different tenant quality, lease terms, maintenance needs and growth prospects.

What is earnest money in a commercial real estate transaction?

Earnest money is a deposit made after the purchase agreement is signed. It shows that the buyer is proceeding seriously and is usually held in escrow under the terms of the contract.

The amount, refundability and release conditions are negotiated. The agreement should clearly state what happens to the deposit during due diligence, financing, title review, environmental review and closing.

Can I withdraw from a commercial real estate purchase?

A buyer's right to withdraw depends on the purchase agreement.

Commercial contracts may include contingencies for inspection, financing, environmental review, title, zoning, appraisal or other approvals. A buyer who terminates within an authorized contingency period may be entitled to the return of the deposit. A buyer who defaults after those rights expire may lose the deposit or face other contractual remedies.

Have a commercial real estate attorney review the agreement before signing.

Do I need a property inspection?

Yes. A commercial property inspection can identify problems involving the structure, roof, pavement, heating and cooling systems, plumbing, electrical service, fire protection and other major components.

Industrial properties may require specialists familiar with heavy electrical service, cranes, compressed air, floor loads, process equipment, loading systems or other operational features.

The inspection should match the property and intended use.

Should I conduct a final property walk-through?

Yes. A final walk-through gives the buyer an opportunity to confirm the property's condition before closing.

The buyer should verify that agreed-upon repairs were completed, included equipment remains in place, tenants have not created new issues and no material damage has occurred since the last inspection.

For vacant or seasonal properties, the walk-through should also check for water damage, freeze damage, vandalism and utility problems.

What documents should I review for an investment property?

Depending on the property, buyers may need to review:

  • Current leases and amendments
  • Rent rolls
  • Tenant payment histories
  • Operating statements
  • Property tax bills
  • Utility bills
  • Service contracts
  • Insurance history
  • Maintenance records
  • Capital improvement records
  • Certificates of occupancy
  • Permits and code records
  • Environmental reports
  • Surveys and title documents

Financial information should be checked against source documents whenever possible.

What is a Section 1031 exchange?

A Section 1031 exchange may allow an owner to defer recognition of certain taxable gains when qualifying real property held for business or investment is exchanged for other qualifying real property.

The transaction must follow federal requirements and strict deadlines. A seller considering an exchange should involve a qualified intermediary and tax advisor before the property is sold or the proceeds are received.

What should I know about buying property near Chautauqua Lake?

Commercial property near Chautauqua Lake may involve considerations that are less common in other parts of Western New York.

Depending on the site and intended use, buyers should investigate:

  • Seasonal demand and revenue
  • Flood zones and drainage
  • Shoreline or waterfront restrictions
  • Water and sewer service
  • Well and septic systems
  • Parking and public access
  • Tourism traffic
  • Short-term or seasonal occupancy
  • Local zoning
  • Environmental conditions
  • Winter access and maintenance
  • Renovation or expansion limits

Hospitality, restaurant, marina, retail and recreational properties should be evaluated based on both the real estate and the operating business.

Selling Commercial Real Estate

How is the value of a commercial property determined?

Commercial property value may be influenced by:

  • Net operating income
  • Lease terms
  • Tenant credit and occupancy
  • Comparable sales
  • Replacement cost
  • Building condition
  • Zoning
  • Location and access
  • Environmental history
  • Redevelopment potential
  • Current market demand

Income-producing properties are often evaluated differently from owner-occupied buildings, industrial facilities or vacant development land.

What should I prepare before listing a commercial property?

Gather the records a serious buyer will request, including:

  • Surveys
  • Deeds and title documents
  • Environmental reports
  • Building plans
  • Leases
  • Rent rolls
  • Income and expense statements
  • Tax bills
  • Utility records
  • Service contracts
  • Capital improvement records
  • Permits and certificates of occupancy
  • Zoning information

Complete and organized records can reduce delays and give buyers more confidence in the property.

How long does it take to sell commercial real estate?

The timeline depends on the property type, asking price, condition, location, financing environment and number of qualified buyers.

A specialized industrial building, development site or seasonal hospitality property may take longer to sell than a well-located property with stable income and strong tenants. The closing process may also take longer when environmental review, financing, zoning approvals or complex leases are involved.

Choosing a Commercial Real Estate Broker

Are you familiar with this commercial real estate market?

Ask whether the broker understands the specific property type and local market.

Western New York is made up of distinct commercial and industrial areas. Conditions in Buffalo, Erie County, Niagara County, Chautauqua County and the communities surrounding Chautauqua Lake can differ in pricing, inventory, zoning, infrastructure and buyer demand.

Have you handled properties like mine?

Experience with the property type matters. Industrial, office, retail, multifamily, hospitality, development land and mixed-use properties each require different knowledge and marketing.

Ask for examples of comparable assignments and how the broker approached pricing, positioning, buyer outreach and negotiations.

How will you market my commercial property?

A commercial marketing plan may include:

  • Professional photography
  • Property brochures
  • Commercial listing platforms
  • Broker-to-broker outreach
  • Direct buyer and investor outreach
  • Email marketing
  • Digital advertising
  • Signage
  • Drone photography
  • Financial summaries
  • Site plans and property documents
  • Confidential marketing when required

The plan should be built around the buyers most likely to purchase the property.

Will I work directly with you or with a team?

Ask who will manage the listing, answer inquiries, conduct showings, qualify buyers and handle negotiations.

A team can provide broader coverage, but responsibilities should be clear. You should know who your primary contact is and how often you will receive updates.

How do you qualify commercial buyers?

A broker should determine whether a buyer has the financial ability, relevant experience and genuine interest to complete the transaction.

Depending on the property, qualification may include proof of funds, lender communication, business background, acquisition criteria and confirmation that the property fits the buyer's intended use.

What professionals may be needed for a commercial transaction?

A commercial purchase or sale may involve:

  • Commercial real estate broker
  • Real estate attorney
  • Commercial lender
  • Accountant or tax advisor
  • Qualified intermediary
  • Property inspector
  • Environmental consultant
  • Engineer
  • Architect
  • Surveyor
  • Appraiser
  • Insurance advisor
  • Contractor
  • Zoning or land-use professional

The professionals needed will depend on the property and transaction.

Certain answers address legal, tax and environmental topics. Consult qualified legal, tax and environmental professionals before acting on any information here. IRS guidance confirms that Section 1031 applies to qualifying real property held for business or investment, but eligibility depends on the specific transaction.

Initiate

Discuss a Transaction

Call directly or send a message below. Michael responds personally.

Office

MLMcVinney & Associates, LLC

Get Directions

Direct Inquiry

Step 1 of 2

Schedule a Consultation

Book Time with Michael

Call or email directly to book a consultation.